We got Lucy one of Costco's amazing cedar chip dog beds when we first got her. She loves it and I love that she smells like cedar chips. Lately, I've been thinking her crate isn't cushy enough and that she needs more than just some blankets to sleep in. So we picked her up a second cedar chip dog bed (don't worry, they are under 20$) and put it in her crate. Now she hardly comes out. People who think that crate training is mean should come see Lucy. She's a poster child for loving her crate.